If the virgins granted to Muslims who go to heaven indeed had no prior Earthly existence and were not themselves “judged” then heaven would consist of two populations of people:
- Those who were judged (and passed)
- Those who were created and placed directly into heaven for the sexual pleasure of those who were judged.
With heaven consisting of these two populations of people, how would you easily be able to identify which group someone belongs? It seems that such an eternal heavenly society would have lots of opportunities for social and psychological strife.
If God created some people and placed them directly into heaven, why doesn’t he do that for all people? The whole concept of “judging” exists simply as a way for religious leaders to have power over the populace.